It seems as though competition to create the best room or "environment" hasn't helped test scores or anything else for that matter.
That's not what I wanted to talk about though. It's the "bulletin board" mentality. My wife is an elementary teacher (has done them all K through 5) and I have witnessed this first hand. Elementary teachers try to one up each others rooms all the time. My wife was staying late one night getting her room ready when she saw another teacher going room to room (open concept no walls/doors) taking pictures of other teachers' bulletin boards and learning areas.
This comes from the top down. And when I mean top, I mean parents. I asked my wife why she spends so much time and she said it's the parents. If a parent sees that your room isn't as "pretty" as another teachers they won't want you and complain until they are moved out. If you have a parent who never goes in your room, chances are they aren't "in touch" with their child's education and it might be harder to get that parental involvement.
After the parents, it's the principal. Human nature strives for recognition. And most principal/administrators will pit teachers against each other. A principal will praise one teacher just to
Lastly, it's the other teachers. The ones that need the attention because they aren't getting enough praise from elsewhere. When you have a teacher that can spend literally 12 hours a days at work, you can't win.
Elementary teachers hurt themselves though. In our district, the elementary schools are being slaughtered due to class size reduction. Instead of banding together and saying "we aren't coming in 3 weeks early to get our rooms ready" or "we aren't spending any extra money in our rooms this year"; they go ahead and do it anyways.
I hope that the elementary teachers can have that proverbial light click on so they can have a voice because right now they look like a bunch of lost sheep.
